Double-click to edit...

Notes on Being a Woman, Whatever That Is

Notes on Being a Woman, Whatever That Is

Womanhood comes with expectations so familiar they usually remain unquestioned. They are simply part of growing up, part of being “normal,” part of knowing who you are. They call you a girl, then a woman, and apparently you’re also supposed to want a boyfriend, then a husband, a child or two, to care about being attractive but not vain, independent but not intimidating, good at looking after people without making a big deal out of how much work that takes. The details change depending on whom you ask, but the general idea remains: there’s a right way to be a woman, and sooner or later someone will let you know how you’re doing.

I know I am perceived as a woman. I know what people tend to assume about me, and I don't have a particularly strong urge to argue with them. I'm not sure whether I don't entirely recognize myself in the category or whether I've simply never felt particularly at home with what it's supposed to mean. The distinction probably matters, though I'm not sure how to make it.

When you’re aroace, you start to notice that some expectations are particularly hard to ignore, especially the assumption that everyone wants the same things, even if they want them in different ways or at different times. When you don't experience certain desires the way people expect, you start noticing how often they use those desires to define what a normal life looks like. But sexuality is only one part of it. Womanhood comes with a whole set of assumptions about who we are, what we want, and what we're here to do. Those assumptions have changed over time, and they’ve never applied to all women in quite the same way.

How strange it is that something so personal can feel so thoroughly pre-defined. I’m still trying to figure out where my own uncertainty ends, and other people’s expectations begin. But why should I have to explain myself for not wanting things other people consider an essential part of being a woman? And why are those things even considered essential in the first place?

The modern idea of womanhood didn't emerge from a timeless truth about human nature. It was shaped by laws, religious institutions, economic arrangements, and cultural ideas about what women were capable of and what their role was. 

In eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Europe, the growing distinction between public and private life helped cement the idea that men belonged in politics and paid employment, while women were responsible for the home and family. The ideal of the respectable wife and devoted mother became particularly influential among the middle classes. Women were expected to do the emotional and domestic labor that let men participate in public life, while their own ambitions were often entirely dismissed. 

But this was never universal. For example, working-class women had long worked for wages, most often alongside their domestic duties. The ideal was powerful precisely because it presented a specific class's circumstances as a model for everyone else.

Motherhood, too, became more than a personal matter or a biological possibility. Over time, it became a woman's defining purpose, tightly tied to both the family's moral health and, eventually, the interests of the nation. Women's reproductive capacities could be cited to justify keeping them out of public life. Their supposed natural flair for care made their unpaid labor seem less like work and more like an obligation.

But women around the world have never lived by a single set of universal rules. Gender roles and expectations have always varied across cultures. They were influenced by different kinship systems, religious traditions, economies, and relationships to property and labor. 

In some societies, family ties and inheritance have followed the maternal line. In others, women's access to property, political authority, or economic independence has been more tightly controlled. The division of labor has also varied: work considered women's responsibility in one context might be performed by men in another. And the value assigned to different kinds of work has rarely been separate from questions of status and power.

These differences don't mean that societies organized around different gender roles were necessarily more equal. A matrilineal system, for example, doesn't automatically give women political authority or freedom from patriarchal control. Nor does women's participation in economic life guarantee that their labor is valued or that they control the resources they help produce. The point is that gender has never operated independently of the wider arrangements through which societies distribute work, property, authority, and responsibility. What gets presented as a natural consequence of being a woman often has much more to do with the social order in which that woman lives.

We often treat desire as private, spontaneous, and entirely our own. We fall in love because we fall in love, right? We have children because we want children, right? Sadly, not. Our understanding of what makes a life fulfilling doesn't develop in a vacuum. Long before we make certain decisions, we absorb stories about what happiness looks like, which ambitions are worth pursuing, and what we'll supposedly regret if we choose differently.

For women, these stories have often revolved around being desirable and desiring in return. Being wanted can become a measure of worth, while wanting someone becomes proof of emotional maturity. Popular culture is full of women whose lives begin when they meet the right person or give birth to a child. Their dissatisfaction usually turns out to be loneliness and yearning, while their ambitions acquire meaning only through other people. Even stories about women who do this tend to show them as temporarily lost, secretly afraid of intimacy, or destined to change their minds. The possibility that they might simply want something else rarely receives the same attention.

I can see this pressure partly because I'm aroace, but it’s not an experience unique to my community. I'm interested in what it reveals beyond that. The (Western) world tells us that freedom means choosing. Less attention goes to the fact that some choices come with social approval and entire institutions built around them, while others leave us constantly explaining ourselves. A woman who wants marriage doesn't usually have to justify why. A woman who doesn't may find herself defending a decision she hasn't even made, against a future other people have already imagined for her.

This is where the narrative of the freedom of choice starts to crumble. Sure, we can make our own decisions, but the world will still treat some as obvious and others as suspicious. 

Poland's political history offers an interesting example of how the language of equality can coexist with remarkably persistent ideas about gender. 

In 1918, the country gained independence. The new constitution gave Polish women the right to vote and stand for election. Obviously, it was an important victory, but political rights rarely translate automatically into autonomy in everyday life. That gap between formal equality and lived experience persisted after the Second World War.

The communist state encouraged women to enter paid employment, presenting their participation in building socialism as both a political duty and a sign of progress. But this wasn't quite the same as imagining women as men's equals in every sphere. During the Stalinist period, women entered some traditionally male industrial jobs, only to face renewed restrictions justified by assumptions about their bodies and reproductive capacities. The division between supposedly appropriate and inappropriate work for women remained firmly in place. Women were needed as workers, but people still understood their work through ideas about what female bodies could do and what women's responsibilities ought to be.

I'm interested in these contradictions because they show how volatile social expectations can be. A society can change what it asks women to do without abandoning its assumptions about what women are. The definition changes; the expectation that a definition should exist at all remains.

Another problem with talking about womanhood as a shared experience is that it assumes women have roughly the same relationship to the expectations placed on them. They don't. Gender never operates on its own, detached from class, race, disability, sexuality, or the circumstances in which someone lives. These factors shape how others perceive us as well as which choices are available to us in the first place.

The ideal of the respectable wife who stays home to raise children, for instance, was never a realistic possibility for every woman. For some, it represented a social status they were expected to aspire to; for others, it depended on domestic workers whose own family responsibilities had to be managed around somebody else's. Similarly, the history of women's access to paid work can't be separated from the women who performed domestic and care work for those with more money and social privilege. What gets presented as a universal female experience often describes a fairly specific group of women.

This is one of the central criticisms raised by Black feminists against mainstream feminist movements that treated white, middle-class women's experiences as representative of women in general. In 1989, legal scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw introduced the term intersectionality to describe how systems of discrimination can overlap. Her work showed how frameworks that considered race and gender separately could fail to account for the experiences of Black women. The issue was that mainstream feminism overlooked some women, and its understanding of inequality was limited by whose experiences it treated as the norm.

The same question matters when we talk about disability and sexuality. Expectations of independence, productivity, sexual desirability, and motherhood don't affect everyone in the same way. Some women are denied autonomy because they're considered incapable of making decisions for themselves; others are pressured to fulfill roles that don't reflect their desires or circumstances. Some are treated as undesirable, while others are expected to make themselves desirable at considerable personal cost.

None of this means there's no shared experience of womanhood, but sharing a category doesn't guarantee a shared life, and expanding the definition of a woman isn't enough if the conditions under which women live remain unequal. 

Contemporary womanhood has acquired a vocabulary of empowerment. Women are encouraged to take up space, set boundaries, pursue their ambitions, embrace their bodies, and refuse to live for other people's approval. These aren’t bad ideas. What's less straightforward is how easily they become another set of standards to live up to. You should know yourself, love yourself, advocate for yourself, have healthy boundaries, and be sufficiently self-aware to recognize when you're failing at any of these things. Even being comfortable with yourself can start to feel like a project you're expected to manage correctly.

Social media makes this particularly visible. There are more ways than ever to present yourself as a woman, and possibilities to find other people who share your experiences. But visibility comes with its own demands. Literally everything is now something you can demonstrate, explain, photograph, and sometimes even monetize. Aesthetics exist for almost every version of womanhood, from the meticulously curated professional to the woman who rejects conventional beauty standards while documenting that rejection in carefully chosen looks. Even opting out can become a recognizable style, complete with its own expectations.

The capitalist commercialization of feminism adds yet another layer to this complex issue. Ideas that should challenge our relationship with the wider society are repackaged as individual lifestyle choices. You can be whoever you want if you want it hard enough. Confidence becomes skincare, independence becomes financial ambition, freedom becomes money, and self-respect becomes a collection of products and habits. The language of liberation starts selling us new ways to perform it. Capitalism is happy.

Self-improvement and personal development offer the perfect solution to problems we should never have to solve alone. Instead of asking why women are expected to be endlessly accommodating, attractive, productive, emotionally competent, and resilient, we should become more adaptable, more self-aware, and better equipped to manage the strain. This way, the system remains intact; we're simply expected to become better at surviving. Even resistance can become another personal development project, with the nagging suspicion that we're not doing enough. The promise is that we can finally be ourselves – provided we put in the work.

I still don't know what to do with the category of a woman. I know what it has meant in law, politics, the workplace, the family, and the countless small judgments through which we learn whether they're getting it right. I know it has given some women a sense of belonging while excluding others, and that its meaning has never been separate from questions of power. 

What I don't know is how much of it belongs to me, beyond the fact that other people have placed me inside it.

Perhaps I've spent so much time trying to understand what womanhood is supposed to mean because I assumed there was something for me to discover, some essential truth obscured by all the rules and expectations. But the history of those expectations offers little reason to believe such a truth exists, waiting patiently to be found. People have made and remade womanhood to serve different purposes, and those placed inside it have never agreed on what it should contain.

I don't want to replace one set of instructions with another, or turn uncertainty into a new identity I have to discover, explore, and explain. There's already enough pressure to make a coherent story out of ourselves.

I'm still not sure what being a woman means to me, but I'm beginning to suspect this uncertainty doesn't need correcting.

Sources:

Untitled

Dear societal expectations

Dear societal expectations