Watercolor for Beginners
Julie finds herself sitting across a restaurant table from Gwen, a situation alarmingly like a date. Julie doesn’t know if she wants it to be a date or not. She also doesn’t want to admit how much this ambivalence suits her purposes—how much she wants to hide in the murkiness.
Julie and Gwen met at a social function marketed to queer professionals. Balancing drinks and plates of finger food, they’d made awkward small talk. Gwen said she painted watercolors, had walked the El Camino several times. Julie said she liked to go running, was trying to write a novel. Hobbies as personalities. Julie told herself that Gwen was an appropriate demographic: a couple years older than herself, an artist—to match Julie’s writing aspirations. Promising friend material. Their original plans for a Saturday morning visit to a local outdoor art festival have morphed into dinner. It’s just a chance to get to know this woman better, Julie tells herself.
Julie picked the restaurant, a new place she’d been wanting to try. It’s starkly elegant, with white walls, large windows and small birch tables lined up against a bench that runs the entire wall. They share a salad—slightly overdressed—and a disappointing flat bread pizza. Oily in all the wrong ways.
“Can I tell you about my ex-husbands?” Gwen asks. Julie wants to talk about her writing, Gwen’s watercolors, but she says yes anyway out of a lifetime habit of being agreeable.
The first husband, father of Gwen’s two children, was distant, cold. Their marriage eventually dissolved due to his indifference, leaving her a struggling single mother. The second husband betrayed her by being emotionally unfaithful. “He treated me well, though,” she explains. “He was very attentive. It was a way to get past the guilt of what he was doing.” Julie gets the sense that this marriage was transactional, a charade of a relationship in exchange for financial security. Gwen had eventually left him and recently come out.
“What about you?” Gwen asks. “Tell me about you.”
Julie hesitates. Gwen’s grim stories have changed the mood, deflated Julie’s hopes of talking about art. Julie doesn’t have stories of ex-husbands, much to her relief. She does have a story of an ex-girlfriend but that is from decades ago, long enough to be suspect, to open her up to questions about being alone for so long. She also has several stories of women she thought she wanted to be in a relationship with but who she ultimately realized she didn’t want to sleep with. She feels deep in her body that she doesn’t want to talk about any of it.
“I’m really busy with work these days,” she says. “I don’t go out much.”
Gwen is relentless, with the zeal of someone who has recently come out.
“When did you realize you were a lesbian?” Gwen asks.
“In grad school,” Julie answers. Again, decades ago.
“What was it like?”
“A lot of other students were gay so it was no big deal. I had a lot of support.”
“But what was it like?”
Julie feels a heaviness settle over her. She isn’t sure she knows what it’s like to be a lesbian. She remembers thinking that coming out would help her make sense of her life up to that point, why, as she neared 30, she’d never been in a relationship, never had sex. She remembers a maudlin conversation with a grad student friend who held her hand as she tearfully told her “I think I’m a lesbian.” She remembers thinking that her life would fall into place after that. Except it hadn’t.
Julie finally tells Gwen a story about her past that smooths over the edges, leaves convenient gaps, chronological and otherwise. She mentions the ex-girlfriend, a very smart, very successful grad student. She omits her emotional devastation when the relationship ended, surprising herself with her matter-of-fact account of how they split up after a year. She omits how she could never match her ex’s passion, her desire. How, when they broke up, her ex said, “I feel like we’re just friends now and that’s okay.” How much it hurt her when the friendship didn’t survive.
Julie goes through the motions for the rest of the evening, producing unenthusiastic conversation about books, TV, movies and then finds herself agreeing to plans for the two of them to meet again the following weekend.
The following day, Julie’s mood is flat. A greyness has settled just on the edge of her vision. Gwen’s interrogation has unsettled her. It’s when she tries to shape her life into the usual narratives that Julie feels like something is wrong with her. She wishes she has a light, fun story to tell, or even something recognizable. Instead her story is one of absence, of things not happening: the repetition of feeling inadequate as a person, steeling herself to venture out into the world, being baffled by the results and retreating back. Now she’s trying to emerge again but she feels like it requires explanation and she doesn’t know how to tell this story.
A week later, Julie decides to muscle through with the plans they’d made and heads over to Gwen’s place. Maybe this time they can talk about art. Gwen meets her at the door, leads her into an unremarkable builders-beige space that has been furnished to match. The living space opens into a spectacular view of the river valley that has to do the heavy lifting of making the space appealing. The only mark of any personality is a watercolor of a red poppy hanging on the wall.
“Is that one of your paintings?” Julie asks.
“Yes.”
“It’s beautiful.”
“Do you want one?” Gwen asks.
Julie is puzzled. “I’d love one but are you sure you want to give away your work.”
“You can paint your own. I’ll show you.”
Gwen rolls out a cart filled with painting supplies, chatting about her favourite sites for downloading watercolor templates. “I have the same red poppy outline if you want to do that.” Gwen shows her how to trace the outline onto the paper. “There’s a few different techniques for controlling the watercolor,” Gwen explains. “A good one for beginners is to use a clean brush to put some water on the paper and then add the paint.”
Julie tries this, watching in amazement as the pigment floats through the water.
“Be careful,” Gwen says. “Don’t let the color get away from you.”
Julie stops painting for a moment. She loves the way the color has traveled beyond the black borders of the poppy’s outline. Gwen looks over. “Don’t worry—you’ll get better at staying in the lines.” Julie considers Gwen’s words. It takes her a moment to recognize the ball of static energy starting to grow in the pit of her belly as anger.
They leave their paintings to dry and Gwen asks Julie if she wants to watch a movie. Julie tries to take advantage of the moment to leave while the evening is still something she can easily walk away from. “I should probably head home,” she says. That’s when Gwen initiates the conversation.
“Where are we at?” Gwen asks. “Are you attracted to me?”
Julie sits in uncomfortable silence. She has never understood attraction, desire. She’d thought she’d been attracted to people in the past but that belief had served her badly, steered her toward too many dead ends. “I don’t know,” she replies.
“That means no,” Gwen says.
Julie feels swept along by some kind of unspoken set of rules. She is relieved, however, by Gwen’s assessment.
“I’m not really cut out for relationships,” Julie says.
“Then why do you keep putting yourself out there?”
Julie feels the static flare inside her. “I just want to meet some new people, make some new friends.”
“I already have too many friends,” Gwen says.
Julie’s eye catches the red poppy on the wall—the watercolor perfectly applied within the outlines of the template—and decides it really is time to leave.
The next day, Julie writes a breakup text in response to a message from Gwen. “I’m sorry I can’t be the woman you’re looking for. I wish you all the best.” She feels lighter. She can’t imagine having too many friends.



