Scented Markers and Invisible Experiences
My kindergarten teacher taught me that we all have five senses: sight, hearing, touch, taste, and smell. I remember there were scented markers in the classroom, brightly colored to correspond to different fruits. My classmates loved to pass these markers around and ask each other what we thought they smelled like.
To me, they all smelled the same.
I quickly learned that this was not the right answer. My classmates would just shove another marker in my face and demand that I smell it and say what I thought it smelled like.
“It smells like a grape,” I finally said, looking at the purple color of the marker.
I knew that everyone had a sense of smell. It was one of those fundamental truths of the world. Therefore, I knew that I must have a sense of smell. It’s just that smell wasn’t really that big of a deal. It clearly mattered a lot to the people around me, and they expected me to match their excitement. But to me, everything smelled the same.
When the social expectation is for everyone to have the same experience, differing experiences become invisible, imperceptible even to those who are living that different experience. I don’t have a sense of smell. I never have. But “not” was not the expectation, and so it took a long time for me to recognize my own anosmia.
As I grew up, when I told my peers about it, their most frequent response was disbelief.
“Really? You can’t smell at all? Never ever? There’s no way you can’t smell. Prove it. Here, smell this.”
And then came the COVID-19 pandemic of 2020. Suddenly, not having a sense of smell was something our society understood could be true. Equally suddenly, people were much more likely to believe me when I said I didn’t have a sense of smell. I still had to reassure them that this was not a “loss.” I’d never had it to begin with, and yes, I was happy and healthy without it.
When I think about my experiences as an aromantic and asexual person, I often find myself comparing them to my experiences with anosmia. In seventh grade, the girls at my cafeteria table loved to ask each other about our crushes. I didn’t have a crush, but I quickly learned that this was not the right answer. They would just keep asking, insisting that I was lying.
So, I made up a crush. I picked a boy who was friendly and said I had a crush on him, and the interrogation ended. At the time, it seemed a bit weird that my peers were no longer curious; they didn’t want to know anything else about the boy or my feelings. It was enough that those feelings supposedly existed. I had fulfilled the social expectation that everyone had a crush, and so they were content. It took another six years for me to learn that asexual and aromantic people existed, and still more time for me to start using those terms to describe myself. I’d been an aro-ace person my whole life, but the expectations of the people around me rendered my own experience invisible.
Just like with my sense of smell, “not” was not the expectation, and all too often, the people around me respond with disbelief.
“Really? You don’t get crushes? You’ve never wanted to have sex with anyone? Never ever? There’s no way. Humans are sexual beings. Love is what makes us human. You just haven’t met the right person yet. Here, let me set you up with someone.”
I try not to let other people’s expectations impact me, but the fact is, we learn what’s normal through social expectations. It’s not always as explicit or direct as a kindergarten teacher listing off the five senses. We look to our parents, our peers, and our community to find models of how life can be. If everyone’s lives look the same, we can wind up unable to see our own life clearly. However, when we are exposed to a diverse range of experiences, we become more able to know ourselves.
This is one way that the internet, particularly social media platforms, can be a useful tool. I don’t need to only listen to the people immediately around me. I can, at any moment, learn about the everyday experiences of countless people around the world. When used intentionally, without relying on algorithms that will only reinforce what we already believe, the internet becomes a window into the diversity of human experience, with multitudinous ways to be happy, healthy, and whole. We can know, better now than ever before, that the expected way to be is not the only way to be. I learned the word “demisexual” from a Tumblr post, and suddenly all the apparent inconsistencies in my desires made sense. I listened to the A-OK podcast, noticed how often I related to the stories of aromantic spectrum guests on the show, and realized that I too was aro. I gained the tools to better reflect on my life, my needs, and my wants, and I felt empowered to seek out the kinds of relationships that would be best for me, specifically, regardless of what other people expect. I’m engaged now, and planning a wedding, because my partner and I choose to be, not because society expects us to follow that path. We’re building our own path, together.
As far as I’m concerned, that’s the best thing we can do: build our own path, together. We need to look past society’s expectations, learn as much as we can about the full diversity of the human experience, encourage each other to reflect on how we each experience the world, and celebrate the truths we discover about ourselves. In doing so, we’ll create a world where we don’t need to lie and say that we think the marker smells like a grape. We can just have fun coloring together.



